predly
All articles

Guide

Why the Same Question Can Show Different Probabilities

Differences in rules, available orders, pricing displays and trading costs can make similar markets show different probabilities.

October 5, 2026 · 0 views

Two prediction markets can appear to ask the same question while showing different probabilities. That gap does not necessarily mean either market is wrong. The contracts may differ, the displayed prices may measure different things, or participants may face different costs and constraints.

When comparing markets on Polymarket, Kalshi or PredictIt, the useful starting point is the contract, not the headline. A meaningful comparison requires checking what each market measures and how its displayed probability is formed.

Similar headlines can hide different questions

A market title is a summary. The resolution rules define the event that determines the payout.

Two contracts with similar titles could use different deadlines, qualifying conditions or sources of confirmation. One might require an official announcement. Another might depend on an event actually taking effect. Those conditions can produce different outcomes without either market being resolved incorrectly.

The treatment of delays, cancellations and disputed results can matter too. If the rules describe different paths to a payout, the markets are not interchangeable. Their probabilities may reasonably differ even when participants share the same view of the underlying situation.

A displayed probability is also a price

For a contract that pays a fixed amount if an event happens, its price can be read as an implied probability relative to that payout. But a market price is not a direct measurement of certainty. It reflects the terms on which participants are willing and able to trade.

The displayed figure also needs interpretation. A page might show the price of the most recent trade, an available offer, or a value calculated from current buying and selling prices.

Those measures can differ. A past transaction shows where a trade occurred. An available offer shows where someone is currently willing to sell, subject to the amount available. Comparing different measures can create an apparent disagreement that is partly a display issue.

Available orders affect the comparison

The amount available at a quoted price matters. A price supported by only a small order may not be available for a larger transaction.

The gap between the highest available buying price and the lowest available selling price matters as well. A wide gap leaves more room for the displayed probability to move without a clear change in participants’ views.

This is why two headline percentages alone provide an incomplete comparison. The surrounding orders help show whether the difference reflects firm trading interest or a market with little available activity. Neither possibility establishes which forecast will prove more accurate.

Prices may update at different times

Even equivalent contracts need not respond to information at the same moment.

An announcement, publication or clarification could prompt activity on one platform before another. If a displayed figure comes from the latest trade, it could remain unchanged simply because no new transaction has occurred.

A comparison should therefore consider when each price was recorded and what information was available then. A recently updated price and an older transaction price are not necessarily competing assessments made under the same conditions.

Some gaps may narrow as activity resumes. Others may remain because participants continue to interpret the information differently.

Different participants can reach different prices

Markets reflect the people participating in them, not every possible observer. Different groups may bring different information, assumptions and reasons for holding a position.

Some participants may focus closely on the event. Others may trade less frequently or respond to broader developments. A participant might also value a position because it offsets another financial exposure, rather than because it represents their preferred forecast.

Available funds and willingness to hold a position can limit how strongly a view affects the price. Someone can believe a market is mispriced without being able or willing to trade enough to change it. Disagreement can therefore persist without implying that anyone has ignored the difference.

Costs and constraints can keep a gap open

A visible price difference is not necessarily a usable opportunity to offset positions across platforms.

Where applicable, fees and funding costs can reduce the value of that difference. Limited order sizes, account restrictions or the time needed to move funds could also prevent matching transactions. Prices might change before both sides are completed.

Resolution differences add another obstacle. Contracts that merely sound alike may not protect against each other if their rules allow different outcomes. For these reasons, the incentive to bring prices closer together may be weaker than the headline gap suggests.

Read the gap as something to explain

A careful comparison follows a simple sequence: check the resolution rules, identify what each displayed price represents, compare the timing, and examine available orders and applicable costs.

If those features align, the remaining difference may reflect a genuine disagreement among participants. If they do not, the percentages may be answering subtly different questions.

The central point is straightforward. A prediction market probability is a price attached to a particular contract under particular trading conditions. Understanding those conditions makes comparisons more useful than treating either displayed figure as a definitive forecast.

More insights

All insights →